I found that armor-all and a toothbrush work pretty good

 

Thanks everyone for the help, I used the Pencil Eraser and worked!

 

The first time a used an eraser, I just stood back and shook my head. All that time I've spent trying ot get the wax off and all I needed was an eraser. Be sure to follow it up with a protectant. It'll look even better.

 

WD-40 works wonders!