Some clinging sound w/ Xcal2
#1
Some clinging sound w/ Xcal2
Sorry if I interpret as clinging or pinging? Well, I just noticed this morning when I start my truck that make unusual sound (for me), and also when I'm on uphill (55mph) makes that noise but not everytime. Is this normal for 91perf tune by Xcal? Your info. will be highly appreciated. But aside from that the truck tune was great Thanks to you Mike(TP)
Last edited by edisonrizon; 08-25-2006 at 02:29 PM.
#4
Originally Posted by edisonrizon
Sorry if I interpret as clinging or pinging? Well, I just noticed this morning when I start my truck that make unusual sound (for me), and also when I'm on uphill (55mph) makes that noise but not everytime. Is this normal for 91perf tune by Xcal? Your info. will be highly appreciated. But aside from that the truck tune was great Thanks to you Mike(TP)
Now - just for giggles.. has anything changed? Fuel, mods, etc? Throwing any codes? And did you datalog your truck yet, as per instructions?
Cheers
Grog
#5
#7
Trending Topics
#8
Sounds like something new is up, as that has not been reported to us before by this gentleman. And unfortunately, the datalogging he did was incomplete, no data at all from the powertrain only a pull on a dyno with a *very* safe A/F ratio - so we do not have what we need to make any changes. And I suspect something is needed, or that the dyno pull was not done correctly,as the power peaked at just 4200 rpm and that is nowhere near correct - it's a stock truck with nothing on it but our tuning as of the time we tuned it, and it should have peaked it's power at 4700 rpm, not just 4200 rpm. This kind of plot tends to indicate a fuel quality problem - or can be seen when people run say, 91-93 octane on their 87 octane tuning, for example.
And by the way - no, the engine is NOT going to detonate (ping) just starting it up - whatever sounds it's making at startup is not going to be detonation.
Aside from making sure the right fuel octane level is always in the tank (because you HAVE to run the low octane fuel out until the low fuel light comes on before you can fill it up with premium and then change to a premium gas tune), I would also look at things like catalytic converter heat shields vibrating, etc., before I would be looking at detonation - especially given the vast amount of retard capability in the knock sensor system, audible detonation is not very likely.
However, this vehicle does need to be properly datalogged, as peaking it's power at 4200 rpm is not correct for a 5.4 3V engine - it should have peaked at least 500 rpm higher, which makes me think we have a technique problem on the dyno, or more likely, the truck was running the wrong fuel for the tune installed. And this can happen, as we just had another customer who actually had 87 in the tank from an improperly filled gas station - the operator at the station actually had 87 octane in the premium gas tank - now that is a beyond-rare scenario of course, but we have seen that happen a couple of times - and with a power peak of only 4200 rpm, *something* is up here, and thus I would return back to the stock tune, run as much fuel as possible out of that tank shy of running it completely out of fuel, fill it up with good quality premium at a different gas station, and then reinstall the premium gas tuning and see what's up.
The bottom line is, this will not be solved here, as alawys, the only way to get proper Tech Support is ny callling us.
And by the way - no, the engine is NOT going to detonate (ping) just starting it up - whatever sounds it's making at startup is not going to be detonation.
Aside from making sure the right fuel octane level is always in the tank (because you HAVE to run the low octane fuel out until the low fuel light comes on before you can fill it up with premium and then change to a premium gas tune), I would also look at things like catalytic converter heat shields vibrating, etc., before I would be looking at detonation - especially given the vast amount of retard capability in the knock sensor system, audible detonation is not very likely.
However, this vehicle does need to be properly datalogged, as peaking it's power at 4200 rpm is not correct for a 5.4 3V engine - it should have peaked at least 500 rpm higher, which makes me think we have a technique problem on the dyno, or more likely, the truck was running the wrong fuel for the tune installed. And this can happen, as we just had another customer who actually had 87 in the tank from an improperly filled gas station - the operator at the station actually had 87 octane in the premium gas tank - now that is a beyond-rare scenario of course, but we have seen that happen a couple of times - and with a power peak of only 4200 rpm, *something* is up here, and thus I would return back to the stock tune, run as much fuel as possible out of that tank shy of running it completely out of fuel, fill it up with good quality premium at a different gas station, and then reinstall the premium gas tuning and see what's up.
The bottom line is, this will not be solved here, as alawys, the only way to get proper Tech Support is ny callling us.
#9
Originally Posted by Superchips_Distributor
Sounds like something new is up, as that has not been reported to us before by this gentleman. And unfortunately, the datalogging he did was incomplete, no data at all from the powertrain only a pull on a dyno with a *very* safe A/F ratio - so we do not have what we need to make any changes. And I suspect something is needed, or that the dyno pull was not done correctly,as the power peaked at just 4200 rpm and that is nowhere near correct - it's a stock truck with nothing on it but our tuning as of the time we tuned it, and it should have peaked it's power at 4700 rpm, not just 4200 rpm. This kind of plot tends to indicate a fuel quality problem - or can be seen when people run say, 91-93 octane on their 87 octane tuning, for example.
Aside from making sure the right fuel octane level is always in the tank (because you HAVE to run the low octane fuel out until the low fuel light comes on before you can fill it up with premium and then change to a premium gas tune), I would also look at things like catalytic converter heat shields vibrating, etc., before I would be looking at detonation - especially given the vast amount of retard capability in the knock sensor system, audible detonation is not very likely.
However, this vehicle does need to be properly datalogged, as peaking it's power at 4200 rpm is not correct for a 5.4 3V engine - it should have peaked at least 500 rpm higher, which makes me think we have a technique problem on the dyno, or more likely, the truck was running the wrong fuel for the tune installed. And this can happen, as we just had another customer who actually had 87 in the tank from an improperly filled gas station - the operator at the station actually had 87 octane in the premium gas tank - now that is a beyond-rare scenario of course, but we have seen that happen a couple of times - and with a power peak of only 4200 rpm, *something* is up here, and thus I would return back to the stock tune, run as much fuel as possible out of that tank shy of running it completely out of fuel, fill it up with good quality premium at a different gas station, and then reinstall the premium gas tuning and see what's up.
Aside from making sure the right fuel octane level is always in the tank (because you HAVE to run the low octane fuel out until the low fuel light comes on before you can fill it up with premium and then change to a premium gas tune), I would also look at things like catalytic converter heat shields vibrating, etc., before I would be looking at detonation - especially given the vast amount of retard capability in the knock sensor system, audible detonation is not very likely.
However, this vehicle does need to be properly datalogged, as peaking it's power at 4200 rpm is not correct for a 5.4 3V engine - it should have peaked at least 500 rpm higher, which makes me think we have a technique problem on the dyno, or more likely, the truck was running the wrong fuel for the tune installed. And this can happen, as we just had another customer who actually had 87 in the tank from an improperly filled gas station - the operator at the station actually had 87 octane in the premium gas tank - now that is a beyond-rare scenario of course, but we have seen that happen a couple of times - and with a power peak of only 4200 rpm, *something* is up here, and thus I would return back to the stock tune, run as much fuel as possible out of that tank shy of running it completely out of fuel, fill it up with good quality premium at a different gas station, and then reinstall the premium gas tuning and see what's up.