after having my kumho mt for about 6 month they allready have bored me out of just lookin at them every day im not dissing them in any way and would recommend them to anyone they've performed very well on everything i've put them threw even in a 4x2 truck ... but yea im lookin for a tire that performs well on sand and mud since thats the only thing there really is to offroad here jaa

ive been looking at
toyo open country mt
bfgoodrich at's
and mickey thompson mtz and baja claws

 

All the tires you have mentioned are good (well I dont think I would consider the claws but thats my own opinion). The key to sand is a wider footprint, the bfg AT's would probably do pretty good there, but would not do as well in the mud as the M/Ts obviously. If I had to pick from your list, I would go with the Toyos.